Logging development guidelines

GitLab Logs play a critical role for both administrators and GitLab team members to diagnose problems in the field.

Don’t use Rails.logger

Currently Rails.logger calls all get saved into production.log, which contains a mix of Rails’ logs and other calls developers have inserted in the codebase. For example: 

Started GET "/gitlabhq/yaml_db/tree/master" for 168.111.56.1 at 2015-02-12 19:34:53 +0200
Processing by Projects::TreeController#show as HTML
  Parameters: {"project_id"=>"gitlabhq/yaml_db", "id"=>"master"}

  ...

  Namespaces"."created_at" DESC, "namespaces"."id" DESC LIMIT 1 [["id", 26]]
  CACHE (0.0ms) SELECT  "members".* FROM "members"  WHERE "members"."source_type" = 'Project' AND "members"."type" IN ('ProjectMember') AND "members"."source_id" = $1 AND "members"."source_type" = $2 AND "members"."user_id" = 1  ORDER BY "members"."created_at" DESC, "members"."id" DESC LIMIT 1  [["source_id", 18], ["source_type", "Project"]]
  CACHE (0.0ms) SELECT  "members".* FROM "members"  WHERE "members"."source_type" = 'Project' AND "members".
  (1.4ms) SELECT COUNT(*) FROM "merge_requests"  WHERE "merge_requests"."target_project_id" = $1 AND ("merge_requests"."state" IN ('opened','reopened')) [["target_project_id", 18]]
  Rendered layouts/nav/_project.html.haml (28.0ms)
  Rendered layouts/_collapse_button.html.haml (0.2ms)
  Rendered layouts/_flash.html.haml (0.1ms)
  Rendered layouts/_page.html.haml (32.9ms)
Completed 200 OK in 166ms (Views: 117.4ms | ActiveRecord: 27.2ms)

These logs suffer from a number of problems:

  1. They often lack timestamps or other contextual information (for example, project ID or user)
  2. They may span multiple lines, which make them hard to find via Elasticsearch.
  3. They lack a common structure, which make them hard to parse by log forwarders, such as Logstash or Fluentd. This also makes them hard to search.

Currently on GitLab.com, any messages in production.log aren’t indexed by Elasticsearch due to the sheer volume and noise. They do end up in Google Stackdriver, but it is still harder to search for logs there. See the GitLab.com logging documentation for more details.

Use structured (JSON) logging

Structured logging solves these problems. Consider the example from an API request: 

{"time":"2018-10-29T12:49:42.123Z","severity":"INFO","duration":709.08,"db":14.59,"view":694.49,"status":200,"method":"GET","path":"/api/v4/projects","params":[{"key":"action","value":"git-upload-pack"},{"key":"changes","value":"_any"},{"key":"key_id","value":"secret"},{"key":"secret_token","value":"[FILTERED]"}],"host":"localhost","ip":"::1","ua":"Ruby","route":"/api/:version/projects","user_id":1,"username":"root","queue_duration":100.31,"gitaly_calls":30}

In a single line, we’ve included all the information that a user needs to understand what happened: the timestamp, HTTP method and path, user ID, and so on.

How to use JSON logging

Suppose you want to log the events that happen in a project importer. You want to log issues created, merge requests, and so on, as the importer progresses. Here’s what to do:

  1. Look at the list of GitLab Logs to see if your log message might belong with one of the existing log files.
  2. If there isn’t a good place, consider creating a new filename, but check with a maintainer if it makes sense to do so. A log file should make it easy for people to search pertinent logs in one place. For example, geo.log contains all logs pertaining to GitLab Geo. To create a new file:
    1. Choose a filename (for example, importer_json.log).

    2. Create a new subclass of Gitlab::JsonLogger: 

      module Gitlab
  module Import
    class Logger < ::Gitlab::JsonLogger
      def self.file_name_noext
        'importer'
      end
    end
   end
end

      By default, Gitlab::JsonLogger will include application context metadata in the log entry. If your logger is expected to be called outside of an application request (for example, in a rake task) or by low-level code that may be involved in building the application context (for example, database connection code), you should call the class method exclude_context! for your logger class, like so: 

      module Gitlab
  module Database
    module LoadBalancing
      class Logger < ::Gitlab::JsonLogger
        exclude_context!

        def self.file_name_noext
          'database_load_balancing'
        end
      end
    end
  end
end

    3. In your class where you want to log, you might initialize the logger as an instance variable: 

      attr_accessor :logger

def initialize
  @logger = ::Import::Framework::Logger.build
end

      It is useful to memoize the logger because creating a new logger each time you log opens a file adds unnecessary overhead.

  3. Now insert log messages into your code. When adding logs, make sure to include all the context as key-value pairs: 

    # BAD
logger.info("Unable to create project #{project.id}")

    # GOOD
logger.info(message: "Unable to create project", project_id: project.id)
  4. Be sure to create a common base structure of your log messages. For example, all messages might have current_user_id and project_id to make it easier to search for activities by user for a given time.

Implicit schema for JSON logging

When using something like Elasticsearch to index structured logs, there is a schema for the types of each log field (even if that schema is implicit / inferred). It’s important to be consistent with the types of your field values, otherwise this might break the ability to search/filter on these fields, or even cause whole log events to be dropped. While much of this section is phrased in an Elasticsearch-specific way, the concepts should translate to many systems you might use to index structured logs. GitLab.com uses Elasticsearch to index log data.

Unless a field type is explicitly mapped, Elasticsearch infers the type from the first instance of that field value it sees. Subsequent instances of that field value with different types either fail to be indexed, or in some cases (scalar/object conflict), the whole log line is dropped.

GitLab.com’s logging Elasticsearch sets ignore_malformed, which allows documents to be indexed even when there are simpler sorts of mapping conflict (for example, number / string), although indexing on the affected fields breaks.

Examples: 

# GOOD
logger.info(message: "Import error", error_code: 1, error: "I/O failure")

# BAD
logger.info(message: "Import error", error: 1)
logger.info(message: "Import error", error: "I/O failure")

# WORST
logger.info(message: "Import error", error: "I/O failure")
logger.info(message: "Import error", error: { message: "I/O failure" })

List elements must be the same type: 

# GOOD
logger.info(a_list: ["foo", "1", "true"])

# BAD
logger.info(a_list: ["foo", 1, true])

Resources:

Include a class attribute

Structured logs should always include a class attribute to make all entries logged from a particular place in the code findable. To automatically add the class attribute, you can include the Gitlab::Loggable module and use the build_structured_payload method. 

class MyClass
  include ::Gitlab::Loggable

  def my_method
    logger.info(build_structured_payload(message: 'log message', project_id: project_id))
  end

  private

  def logger
    @logger ||= Gitlab::AppJsonLogger.build
  end
end

Logging durations

Similar to timezones, choosing the right time unit to log can impose avoidable overhead. So, whenever challenged to choose between seconds, milliseconds or any other unit, lean towards seconds as float (with microseconds precision, that is, Gitlab::InstrumentationHelper::DURATION_PRECISION).

In order to make it easier to track timings in the logs, make sure the log key has _s as suffix and duration within its name (for example, view_duration_s).

Multi-destination Logging

GitLab transitioned from structured to JSON logs. However, through multi-destination logging, the logs can be recorded in multiple formats.

How to use multi-destination logging

Create a new logger class, inheriting from MultiDestinationLogger and add an array of loggers to a LOGGERS constant. The loggers should be classes that descend from Gitlab::Logger. For example, the user-defined loggers in the following examples could be inheriting from Gitlab::Logger and Gitlab::JsonLogger, respectively.

You must specify one of the loggers as the primary_logger. The primary_logger is used when information about this multi-destination logger is displayed in the application (for example, using the Gitlab::Logger.read_latest method).

The following example sets one of the defined LOGGERS as a primary_logger. 

module Gitlab
  class FancyMultiLogger < Gitlab::MultiDestinationLogger
    LOGGERS = [UnstructuredLogger, StructuredLogger].freeze

    def self.loggers
      LOGGERS
    end

    def primary_logger
      UnstructuredLogger
    end
  end
end

You can now call the usual logging methods on this multi-logger. For example: 

FancyMultiLogger.info(message: "Information")

This message is logged by each logger registered in FancyMultiLogger.loggers.

Passing a string or hash for logging

When passing a string or hash to a MultiDestinationLogger, the log lines could be formatted differently, depending on the kinds of LOGGERS set.

For example, let’s partially define the loggers from the previous example: 

module Gitlab
  # Similar to AppTextLogger
  class UnstructuredLogger < Gitlab::Logger
    ...
  end

  # Similar to AppJsonLogger
  class StructuredLogger < Gitlab::JsonLogger
    ...
  end
end

Here are some examples of how messages would be handled by both the loggers.

  1. When passing a string 
FancyMultiLogger.info("Information")

# UnstructuredLogger
I, [2020-01-13T18:48:49.201Z #5647]  INFO -- : Information

# StructuredLogger
{:severity=>"INFO", :time=>"2020-01-13T11:02:41.559Z", :correlation_id=>"b1701f7ecc4be4bcd4c2d123b214e65a", :message=>"Information"}
  1. When passing a hash 
FancyMultiLogger.info({:message=>"This is my message", :project_id=>123})

# UnstructuredLogger
I, [2020-01-13T19:01:17.091Z #11056]  INFO -- : {"message"=>"Message", "project_id"=>"123"}

# StructuredLogger
{:severity=>"INFO", :time=>"2020-01-13T11:06:09.851Z", :correlation_id=>"d7e0886f096db9a8526a4f89da0e45f6", :message=>"This is my message", :project_id=>123}

Logging context metadata (through Rails or Grape requests)

Gitlab::ApplicationContext stores metadata in a request lifecycle, which can then be added to the web request or Sidekiq logs.

The API, Rails and Sidekiq logs contain fields starting with meta. with this context information.

Entry points can be seen at:

Adding attributes

When adding new attributes, make sure they’re exposed within the context of the entry points above and:

  • Pass them within the hash to the with_context (or push) method (make sure to pass a Proc if the method or variable shouldn’t be evaluated right away)
  • Change Gitlab::ApplicationContext to accept these new values
  • Make sure the new attributes are accepted at Labkit::Context

See our HOWTO: Use Sidekiq metadata logs for further knowledge on creating visualizations in Kibana.

The fields of the context are currently only logged for Sidekiq jobs triggered through web requests. See the follow-up work for more information.

Logging context metadata (through workers)

Additional metadata can be attached to a worker through the use of the ApplicationWorker#log_extra_metadata_on_done method. Using this method adds metadata that is later logged to Kibana with the done job payload. 

class MyExampleWorker
  include ApplicationWorker

  def perform(*args)
    # Worker performs work
    # ...

    # The contents of value will appear in Kibana under `json.extra.my_example_worker.my_key`
    log_extra_metadata_on_done(:my_key, value)
  end
end

See this example which logs a count of how many artifacts are destroyed per run of the ExpireArtifactsWorker.

Exception Handling

It often happens that you catch the exception and want to track it.

It should be noted that manual logging of exceptions is not allowed, as:

  1. Manual logged exceptions can leak confidential data,
  2. Manual logged exception very often require to clean backtrace which reduces the boilerplate,
  3. Very often manually logged exception needs to be tracked to Sentry as well,
  4. Manually logged exceptions does not use correlation_id, which makes hard to pin them to request, user and context in which this exception was raised,
  5. Manually logged exceptions often end up across multiple files, which increases burden scraping all logging files.

To avoid duplicating and having consistent behavior the Gitlab::ErrorTracking provides helper methods to track exceptions:

  1. Gitlab::ErrorTracking.track_and_raise_exception: this method logs, sends exception to Sentry (if configured) and re-raises the exception,
  2. Gitlab::ErrorTracking.track_exception: this method only logs and sends exception to Sentry (if configured),
  3. Gitlab::ErrorTracking.log_exception: this method only logs the exception, and does not send the exception to Sentry,
  4. Gitlab::ErrorTracking.track_and_raise_for_dev_exception: this method logs, sends exception to Sentry (if configured) and re-raises the exception for development and test environments.

It is advised to only use Gitlab::ErrorTracking.track_and_raise_exception and Gitlab::ErrorTracking.track_exception as presented on below examples.

Consider adding additional extra parameters to provide more context for each tracked exception.

Example 

class MyService < ::BaseService
  def execute
    project.perform_expensive_operation

    success
  rescue => e
    Gitlab::ErrorTracking.track_exception(e, project_id: project.id)

    error('Exception occurred')
  end
end

class MyService < ::BaseService
  def execute
    project.perform_expensive_operation

    success
  rescue => e
    Gitlab::ErrorTracking.track_and_raise_exception(e, project_id: project.id)
  end
end

Default logging locations

For self-managed users and GitLab.com, GitLab is deployed in two ways:

Omnibus GitLab log handling

Omnibus GitLab logs inside component-specific directories within /var/log/gitlab: 

# ls -al /var/log/gitlab
total 200
drwxr-xr-x 27 root              root        4096 Apr 29 20:28 .
drwxrwxr-x 19 root              syslog      4096 Aug  5 04:08 ..
drwx------  2 gitlab-prometheus root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 alertmanager
drwx------  2 root              root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 crond
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 gitaly
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 gitlab-exporter
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 gitlab-kas
drwx------  2 git               root       45056 Aug  6 13:18 gitlab-rails
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  5 04:18 gitlab-shell
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 May 24  2023 gitlab-sshd
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 gitlab-workhorse
drwxr-xr-x  2 root              root       12288 Aug  1 00:20 lets-encrypt
drwx------  2 root              root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 logrotate
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 mailroom
drwxr-x---  2 root              gitlab-www 12288 Aug  6 00:18 nginx
drwx------  2 gitlab-prometheus root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 node-exporter
drwx------  2 gitlab-psql       root        4096 Aug  6 15:00 pgbouncer
drwx------  2 gitlab-psql       root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 postgres-exporter
drwx------  2 gitlab-psql       root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 postgresql
drwx------  2 gitlab-prometheus root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 prometheus
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 puma
drwxr-xr-x  2 root              root       32768 Aug  1 21:32 reconfigure
drwx------  2 gitlab-redis      root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 redis
drwx------  2 gitlab-redis      root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 redis-exporter
drwx------  2 registry          root        4096 Aug  6 04:08 registry
drwx------  2 gitlab-redis      root        4096 May  6 06:30 sentinel
drwx------  2 git               root        4096 Aug  6 13:05 sidekiq

You can see in the example above that the following components store logs in the following directories:

Component Log directory
GitLab Rails /var/log/gitlab/gitlab-rails
Gitaly /var/log/gitlab/gitaly
Sidekiq /var/log/gitlab/sidekiq
GitLab Workhorse /var/log/gitlab/gitlab-workhorse

The GitLab Rails directory is probably where you want to look for the log files used with the Ruby code above.

logrotate is used to watch for all *.log files.

Cloud Native GitLab log handling

A Cloud Native GitLab pod writes GitLab logs directly to /var/log/gitlab without creating additional subdirectories. For example, the webservice pod runs gitlab-workhorse in one container and puma in another. The log file directory in the latter looks like: 

git@gitlab-webservice-default-bbd9647d9-fpwg5:/$ ls -al /var/log/gitlab
total 181420
drwxr-xr-x 2 git  git       4096 Aug  2 22:58 .
drwxr-xr-x 4 root root      4096 Aug  2 22:57 ..
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git          0 Aug  2 18:22 .gitkeep
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git   46524128 Aug  6 20:18 api_json.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git      19009 Aug  2 22:58 application_json.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git        157 Aug  2 22:57 auth_json.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git       1116 Aug  2 22:58 database_load_balancing.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git         67 Aug  2 22:57 grpc.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git          0 Aug  2 22:57 production.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git  138436632 Aug  6 20:18 production_json.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git         48 Aug  2 22:58 puma.stderr.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git        266 Aug  2 22:58 puma.stdout.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git         67 Aug  2 22:57 service_measurement.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git         67 Aug  2 22:57 sidekiq_client.log
-rw-r--r-- 1 git  git     733809 Aug  6 20:18 web_exporter.log

gitlab-logger is used to tail all files in /var/log/gitlab. Each log line is converted to JSON if necessary and sent to stdout so that it can be viewed via kubectl logs.

Additional steps with new log files

  1. Consider log retention settings. By default, Omnibus rotates any logs in /var/log/gitlab/gitlab-rails/*.log every hour and keep at most 30 compressed files. On GitLab.com, that setting is only 6 compressed files. These settings should suffice for most users, but you may need to tweak them in Omnibus GitLab.

  2. On GitLab.com all new JSON log files generated by GitLab Rails are automatically shipped to Elasticsearch (and available in Kibana) on GitLab Rails Kubernetes pods. If you need the file forwarded from Gitaly nodes then submit an issue to the production tracker or a merge request to the gitlab_fluentd project. See this example.

  3. Be sure to update the GitLab CE/EE documentation and the GitLab.com runbooks.

Finding new log files in Kibana (GitLab.com only)

On GitLab.com all new JSON log files generated by GitLab Rails are automatically shipped to Elasticsearch (and available in Kibana) on GitLab Rails Kubernetes pods. The json.subcomponent field in Kibana will allow you to filter by the different kinds of log files. For example the json.subcomponent will be production_json for entries forwarded from production_json.log.

It’s also worth noting that log files from Web/API pods go to a different index than log files from Sidekiq pods. Depending on where you log from you will find the logs in a different index pattern.

Control logging visibility

An increase in the logs can cause a growing backlog of unacknowledged messages. When adding new log messages, make sure they don’t increase the overall volume of logging by more than 10%.

Deprecation notices

If the expected volume of deprecation notices is large:

  • Only log them in the development environment.
  • If needed, log them in the testing environment.